Skip to content

How big can a monster get before its bones break?

Scale an animal up and see its weight, its bones, its speed and its heartbeat by the square-cube law.

×

×

Key values as a table
ThingHeight
Gorilla17.5 m
House8 m
10-storey block30 m

Height

17.5 m

Gorilla, 10 times larger, weighs 160 t. Its legs would break under its own weight.

The whole monster

Height
17.5 m
Mass
160 t (1,000 times heavier)
Bones standing still
safety 0.75, breaks beyond ×7.5
Bones walking
safety 0.6, breaks beyond ×6
Bones running
safety 0.3, breaks beyond ×3
Leg bones needed to stay safe
3.2 times thicker for their length
Relaxed walking speed
16.5 km/h
Walk becomes a run at
23.3 km/h
Resting heartbeat
12 per minute (real animal: 68)
Food energy at rest
560,000 kcal a day

What it means

  • Its legs would break under its own weight.
  • 10 times larger means 100 times the bone area but 1,000 times the weight. That is the square-cube law.
  • The animal keeps its shape and density. Real animals change shape as they grow, with thicker legs and a lower build.

Fan-made fun calculations. Not affiliated with or endorsed by the owners of any film, series or book named here.

Scale an animal up and see its weight, its bones, its speed and its heartbeat by the square-cube law.

How to use

  1. Pick an animal and say how big to make it: so many times larger, or a height in metres.
  2. Drag the handle on its head to grow or shrink it beside the landmarks.
  3. Read its weight, whether its bones would hold standing, walking and running, how fast it could walk and how its heart would beat.

How it works

Double every length of an animal and its weight does not double, it grows eight times, because weight follows volume. But a bone's strength follows its cross-section, which only grows four times. So the bigger the animal, the more each square centimetre of bone has to carry. This is the square-cube law, known since Galileo and explained for animals by J. B. S. Haldane in his essay On Being the Right Size.

Scale an animal up k times and the mass becomes k³ times larger, the bone area k² times, so the stress on the bone is k times larger. Biewener measured that real leg bones have a safety factor of about 2 to 4 against breaking at an animal's fastest gait. A running step loads the leg with about 2.5 times the body weight, a walking step 1.25 times, and standing 1 times, so the scaled animal's safety factor is its real one times the load ratio divided by k. For example, a human scaled up 10 times weighs 70 tonnes and has a standing safety factor of 3 × 2.5 ÷ 10 = 0.75: below 1, so its legs would break just from standing.

The tool adds speed from the Froude number, v² = Fr × g × leg length (walking at Fr 0.25, walk turning into a run at 0.5), the resting heartbeat of 241 × mass^−0.25 per minute (Stahl) and the food energy of 70 × mass^0.75 kilocalories a day (Kleiber). The animal keeps its shape and density; real animals grow thicker legs, which is why an elephant is not a giant gazelle. The reference sizes are typical adults and approximate.

Worked example

What if a human grew ten times larger?

  1. Height: 1.7 m × 10 = 17 m; mass 70 kg × 10³ = 70 tonnes.
  2. Bone safety: real 3 at a run (2.5 times the weight). Standing: 3 × 2.5 ÷ 10 = 0.75; running: 3 ÷ 10 = 0.3.

Both are below 1, so the legs would break when standing; the safe size for standing is about 7.5 times larger.

Frequently asked questions

What is the square-cube law?

When something grows, its areas grow with the square of the scale and its volume, and so its weight, with the cube. The weight grows faster than the strength of the bones that carry it.

Could a monster like King Kong or Godzilla exist?

Not with the shape and bones of a normal animal. A gorilla ten times larger has legs that break just standing. A real giant would need much thicker legs, a different build or lighter, stronger materials.

Why is an elephant not just a big deer?

The largest land animals have thick, straight legs under the body, which keeps the bones loaded in compression. A scaled-up deer would have legs too thin for its weight.

Why does a big animal have a slower heartbeat?

Heart rate follows body mass to the power minus one quarter. A mouse's heart beats hundreds of times a minute, an elephant's about thirty.

How strong are real bones?

Bone fails at roughly 100 to 200 megapascals. Animals keep a safety factor of about 2 to 4 at their fastest gait, so they rarely come near the limit. You can change the factor in the extra field.

Send feedback