Skip to content

How fast does a double pendulum turn chaotic?

Two nearly identical double pendulums start a hair apart. Watch them swing together, then drift into completely different paths.

Double pendulum

Key values as a table
TimeA lower arm angleB lower arm angleGap
0 s120°120°0 m
5 s−91°−92°0 m
10 s759°895°0.76 m
15 s−216°609°2.26 m
20 s−1,493°338°0.84 m
25 s−1,823°692°0.24 m
30 s−2,211°1,238°0.84 m

Result

Drifted apart after: 7.1 s The lower bobs of the two pendulums are more than a tenth of the reach apart after 7.1 s, although they started almost together. Time into the swing: 15 s
Start
°

°

At the start, drag a bob of pendulum A: the dashed line shows its next three seconds, and letting go runs it.

Time into the swing

Two nearly identical double pendulums start a hair apart. Watch them swing together, then drift into completely different paths.

Play, pause, step and change the speed on the picture, zoom in on the swing, and see the next swing while you drag a start angle.

How to use

  1. Set the start angles of the two arms, or drag the two dots of pendulum A on the picture. Angles count from hanging straight down.
  2. Press Play on the picture, or drag the time slider, and watch pendulum A (solid) and its twin B (dashed) swing. B starts a hair off A. Step moves on a little, and the speed choice slows it down.
  3. Read how many seconds pass before the two lower bobs drift apart. The Pendulums tab changes the starting difference, the masses and the arm lengths.

How it works

A single pendulum is predictable: the same start always gives the same swing, and a small change in the start only changes the swing a little. Hang a second pendulum from the end of the first and everything changes. The motion becomes chaotic, which means a tiny difference at the start grows into a completely different path.

Each arm's angle follows from Lagrange's equations for two point masses on rigid arms (Taylor, Classical Mechanics, 2005, section 11.4). The page solves them step by step with the fourth-order Runge-Kutta method, 200 steps for every second. The two copies start with the upper arm nudged by the chosen difference, for example 0.01 degrees. Early on the gap between them grows roughly like e raised to λt, where λ is the Lyapunov exponent, typically one to three per second for large swings, so a hundredth of a degree is visible after ten seconds or so.

The model is ideal: no friction, no air, rigid massless arms. Energy is conserved in theory, so the energy drift shown is the numerical error of the simulation. For small swings the double pendulum is not chaotic at all: both arms move in two clean rhythms. Chaos needs big angles.

Method

No outside data is used: the result is worked out directly from the formula explained under How it works.

Sources and methods

Frequently asked questions

What does chaotic mean for a double pendulum?

It means the motion is completely determined by the start, yet a tiny difference in the start leads to a very different motion later. You cannot predict it far ahead in practice.

Why do the two pendulums look the same at first?

The difference between them starts tiny and grows gradually. For a few seconds it stays too small to see, then it grows quickly until the paths have nothing to do with each other.

Does a bigger start angle make it more chaotic?

Yes. Near hanging straight down, the double pendulum swings in simple regular patterns. Starting high up, above the pivot's height, makes it chaotic most quickly.

How accurate is the simulation?

The energy drift in the result shows the numerical error. It stays tiny for most starts. Because the system is chaotic, even a tiny error changes the far future, so the exact path after many seconds is not reliable, but the way it drifts apart is.

Is this the same as the butterfly effect?

Yes, it is a small, clean example. A tiny cause grows into a big difference, as in weather forecasts, which is why they lose accuracy after a week or two.

Send feedback